Use Emergency Savings or Borrow? Compare the Cost and What Is Left Afterwards

You've done the hard part. You built some savings. Now the car needs a $500 repair and you're hesitating. Using the money feels like undoing all that work. Borrowing feels like paying to avoid using money you already have.

Both instincts make sense. The right choice depends on what your savings are for, what else is coming, and what borrowing would actually cost. Here's a way to compare them side by side.

Step 1: Check whether the cost fits the purpose of your savings

Start with a simple question: what did you save this money for?

  • An emergency fund exists for exactly this kind of moment. An unexpected car repair, a vet bill or a broken appliance is what it's there to cover.
  • Savings for a specific goal, like a bond for a move or a bill due next month, are already spoken for. Using them may just move the problem to a later date.

If you've got an emergency fund and this is a genuine emergency, using it is often the simplest path. That's not a failure of saving. It's saving doing its job. Our guide to building a home emergency fund covers how to set one up and refill it.

Step 2: Look at what else is coming up

Before you decide, check the next couple of months. Are there other bills, renewals or known costs ahead that your savings would need to cover? Is your income steady, or could it change?

If a large bill is due soon after, emptying your savings now could leave you exposed to it. If nothing big is coming and your income is stable, the risk of running your savings down for a while is smaller.

There's no minimum buffer that suits everyone. It depends on your household, your job and what you'd need to keep going if something else went wrong.

Step 3: Compare the two options with clear assumptions

Here's a worked illustration. All figures are invented to show the method, including the loan terms, which are hypothetical and not a Beforepay offer.

Starting point:

  • Unexpected expense: $500
  • Accessible savings: $900
  • Money left over each fortnight after essentials and bills: $150 (the same in both options)

Option A: Pay from savings

  • Savings drop from $900 to $400 straight away
  • You put the $150 spare each fortnight back into savings
  • After four fortnights: $400 + $600 = $1,000 in savings
  • Borrowing cost: $0

Option B: Borrow

  • Hypothetical loan: $500, with a $25 fee and $15 interest, repaid in four fortnightly instalments of $135 ($540 in total)
  • Savings stay at $900
  • Each fortnight, $135 of your $150 spare goes to the repayment, and $15 goes into savings
  • After four fortnights: $900 + $60 = $960 in savings
  • Borrowing cost: $40

What the comparison shows

After eight weeks, Option A leaves you $40 better off. That $40 is exactly the cost of borrowing.

But Option B kept $900 in your account the whole time, while Option A dropped you to $400 for a while. So the real question is: is having a bigger buffer for those eight weeks worth $40 to you?

  • If your income is steady and nothing else is likely, Option A may be the simpler, cheaper choice.
  • If another known cost could land in that window, or your income is uncertain, some people decide keeping the bigger buffer is worth the cost.

Two cautions. First, comparing interest rates alone can mislead. Fees and the length of the loan matter, so compare the total repayable. Second, borrowing only works if the repayments genuinely fit. If $135 a fortnight would squeeze your groceries or rent, Option B creates a new problem.

Step 4: Plan your next few pay cycles either way

Whichever path you choose, make a plan for the next few pays:

  • If you used savings: set up an automatic transfer to rebuild them, even if it's small to start.
  • If you borrowed: mark each repayment date on your calendar alongside your other bills and check the money will be there.

Our guide on how much you need to borrow walks through testing repayments against your next pays in more detail.

How Beforepay fits

If you've weighed it up and a short-term loan suits your situation, here's how Beforepay's products work.

If a bill lands before payday, a Beforepay Pay Advance can bridge the gap until payday. It is a short-term loan of $50 to $2,000, repaid within 62 days in up to 4 instalments, with a fixed 5% setup fee and interest up to 24% p.a. Eligibility criteria and T&Cs apply.

For larger amounts, a Beforepay Personal Loan runs from $2,001 to $5,000 over terms of 3 to 12 months, with the same fixed 5% setup fee, interest up to 24% p.a. and a 29.50% p.a. comparison rate. Pay Advance and Personal Loans of $5,000 or less don't involve a credit check (we look at your income and spending instead), and neither product charges late fees or early repayment fees. A customer may hold only one active Beforepay loan at a time.

Every application is subject to assessment, and approval is never automatic. The full criteria are on the eligibility page.

When neither option covers it

Sometimes the expense is bigger than your savings and more than you could comfortably repay. If that's where you are, contact the provider to ask about a payment plan or hardship support, and consider speaking with a free financial counsellor through the National Debt Helpline on 1800 007 007. It's free and confidential, and they can help you work out priorities.

Questions to ask yourself

  1. What is this savings money for?
  2. What other costs are due in the next two months?
  3. How steady is my income over that period?
  4. What's the total cost of borrowing, including all fees and interest?
  5. Would the repayments fit alongside my essentials?
  6. How much buffer would I have left under each option, and does that feel safe?

If you'd like help thinking it through for your own situation, a licensed financial adviser or a free financial counsellor can talk you through the options.

This article is general information only. It does not take your personal circumstances into account and it is not financial, tax or legal advice.

FAQs

Should I use my emergency fund or borrow for an unexpected expense?

It depends on the purpose of your savings, what other costs are coming up and the full cost of borrowing. Compare what you'd have left in savings, what you'd repay in fees and interest, and how each option affects your next few pays. There's no single right answer for everyone.

How much should I keep in an emergency fund?

There's no amount that suits everyone. It depends on your income, household, job security and regular costs. Many people start with a small, reachable target and build from there. The aim is to have accessible money for genuine surprises so you're not relying on credit for every unexpected cost.

What if neither my savings nor borrowing covers the cost?

Contact the provider to ask about a payment plan or hardship support, and speak with a free financial counsellor through the National Debt Helpline on 1800 007 007. They can help you work out priorities and negotiate with creditors, and it costs nothing.

Beforepay Team
November 19, 2026

Disclaimer: Information provided by Beforepay is factual information only and does not constitute financial, legal or tax advice. The views expressed in articles, including those of guest contributors, are general commentary only and should not be relied upon as a substitute for professional advice. While Beforepay Group Limited and its related bodies corporate believe the information provided is accurate at the time of publication, no representation or warranty is made as to its accuracy, completeness or reliability. To the extent permitted by law, Beforepay disclaims all liability arising from reliance on this information. Please read our Terms of Service before using Beforepay’s services.

Applications are typically approved in under 60 seconds, though some applications may require additional review.

† Approved loan amounts are subject to Beforepay’s lending criteria and verification requirements.

‡ Comparison rate calculated on a $2,500 loan over a 2-year term.

‡ WARNING: This comparison rate is true only for the example given and may not include all fees and charges. Different terms, fees or loan amounts may result in a different comparison rate.

Stay Up To Date

Enter your email to get the latest financial tips and Beforepay news delivered straight to your inbox.

Thanks for subscribing!
Keep an eye on your inbox for the latest financial tips and Beforepay updates.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Beforepay
PAY ADVANCE
Personal Loans
From smaller short-term costs to bigger planned expenses.
Help with bills, groceries or unexpected expenses before payday.
For larger expenses like car repairs, travel or home essentials.
Get Started
White arrow pointing right